Pageant Material

Pageant Material is the second studio album by American singer-songwriter Kacey Musgraves, released June 23, 2015, through Mercury Nashville. Musgraves co-wrote all 13 tracks and co-produced the album with Luke Laird and Shane McAnally. The album made numerous "Best Albums of 2015" lists and was nominated for Best Country Album at the 58th Grammy Awards.

"You can't have a potty mouth or an opinion. In the South, getting judged on superficial stuff is a real thing. And I'm not attacking the people that might get something positive out of pageantry; I'm just not into being judged in that way."

On Pageant Material, Musgraves continues to explore themes of small-town life and staying grounded. She noted that country music often draws on "real things" people experience in everyday life, which she wanted to reflect beyond typical breakup songs.^[1] Calling the album as "nature of [her]",^[2] she said the record reflects her discomfort with being judged on superficial expectations, particularly those placed on women. She remarked that in the American South, people are often judged on such standards, adding that she would "rather lose for what I am than win for something that I'm not".^[3] The album was inspired by classic country and pop records by artists such as Glen Campbell, Jim Croce, Bobbie Gentry, Marty Robbins, Roger Miller, and Charley Pride. She explained that she aimed for a consistent tone across the album and entered the recording process with a clearer artistic vision.^[4]

Most of Pageant Material was recorded live in Nashville's historic RCA Studio A.^[5] In an interview with The Boot published May 21, 2015, Musgraves described the recording process: "We recorded most everything in a big circle in one of my favorite old studios on the planet – historic RCA Studio A in Nashville. That lent itself to the record having that concise feel that we wanted. Then we added a 10-piece string section later."^[6] Musgraves also said that recording Pageant Material was more exciting because she had a clearer sense of her artistic direction. She further noted that most of the album was recorded live with musicians performing together in the same room, which gave the record a more concise and classic sound compared to her previous record Same Trailer Different Park (2013).^[7] The album was largely recorded live, with Musgraves joined by her touring band and additional studio musicians.^[1]

Musgraves said her voice had improved since Same Trailer Different Park and that she had a clearer sense of the musical direction she wanted to pursue while working on the album. She also noted that the artwork was being finalized during the process.^[2]

Pageant Material pays homage to the traditional country sound of Musgraves' influences, including Dolly Parton, Loretta Lynn and Willie Nelson, the latter of whom makes a guest appearance.^[8] Across its 13 tracks, it blends country with elements of "rockabilly" and occasional surf rock influences, according to Mike Ayers of The Wall Street Journal.^[1] The album continues Musgraves' reflections on life, relationships and her career, while maintaining what Angela Stefano of Taste of Country described as an "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" approach to her sound and collaborators.^[9] The singer also approaches small-town life in a way that is "sometimes harsh but more often affectionate", incorporating "irreverent philosophical musings" delivered with a "sly sense of humor", as noted by Bob Paxman of Nash Country Weekly.^[10] Helen Brown of The Daily Telegraph described the record as a "successful repetition of the formula", highlighting its "sweet, crisp country licks" and "witty twists of live-and-let-live philosophy".^[11] Writing for AllMusic, Stephen Thomas Erlewine noted that the album often favors a softer sound.^[12]

Critics also highlighted Musgraves' songwriting, with Spin's Brennan Carley noting that the storytelling of Pageant Material is expansive enough to "fill a memoir".^[13] Joe Breen of The Irish Times wrote that it inherits the attitude of her debut but is more measured and reserved, staying conscious of its Nashville roots while continuing to "rock the lyrical boat".^[14] In a review for Pitchfork, Jessica Hopper described the album as having an "analog and organic" sound, with Musgraves backed by a small band and arrangements featuring pedal steel and occasional string sections; she also observed that the album's songs avoid dramatic buildups, writing that the choruses "do not explode, they merely unfurl".^[15]

Built around pedal steel and banjo with a hand-clapped rhythm, "Biscuits" accompanies lyrics about "treatise on privacy", according to Randall Roberts of Los Angeles Times.^[16] The Guardian's Grady Smith noted that it lyrically reflects Musgraves' recurring perspective of personal independence, with the chorus advising listeners to "mind your own biscuits, and life will be gravy" as a playful call to ignore outside judgment and live freely.^[17] "Dime Store Cowgirl" references milestones from Musgraves' early career, while highlighting her "humble roots" and continued attachment to her hometown.^[3] Billy Dukes of Taste of Country noted that its pedal steel accents accompany Musgraves' "city-by-city" narrative about her story.^[18] According to Country Universe's Jonathan Keefe, the song adopts a more "different" tone than some of Musgraves' earlier singles, emphasizing "humility and self-deprecation"; its lyrics combine references to milestones in her career with more everyday experiences.^[19] The title track was described by Musgraves as a "satirical song" that "pokes fun" at herself and her imperfections, inspired by imagery of a hazy, retro-style beauty pageant.^[4] "This Town" opens with a spoken-word recording of Musgraves' grandmother telling a story, which Musgraves had secretly recorded prior to her death.^[20] "High Time" and "Fine" are described as "deliberate and hazy" by Stephen Thomas Erlewine of AllMusic.^[12]

Pageant Material was announced on May 12, 2015.^[8][21] Promotional appearances in the media to support the album included several performances, such as The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon (June 9)^[22] and Late Night with Seth Meyers (June 10).^[23] The album was released on June 23, and she performed in Good Morning America^[24] that day to celebrate its release.^[25][26] A day later, she performed at The View^[27] and more live performances in Jimmy Kimmel Live! (September 15),^[28] CMA Awards (November 5),^[29] The Late Show with Stephen Colbert (January 8, 2016)^[30] and The Late Late Show with James Corden (April 6).^[31] On June 26, 2015, Musgraves performed "Follow Your Arrow" for National Public Radio's Tiny Desk Concerts in support of the legalization of same-sex marriage in the United States, which took place on the same day.^[32]

Musgraves co-wrote every track in the album, producing them with Luke Laird and Shane McAnally.^[33][34] Musgraves' younger sister, Kelly Christine Sutton, is credited with the album cover's photograph and design.^[4] As noted by Christina Vinson of Taste of Country, the album cover features Musgraves against a "shiny red backdrop", wearing a tiara and styled with voluminous hair.^[35]

Musgraves had performed "Biscuits" during her tour prior to its official release, including a performance at the Ryman Auditorium where many radio programmers first heard the song. The track was later announced as the lead single from her then-upcoming second album,^[36] released on March 2 as the album's first promotional single.^[37] Two weeks later, it was sent to country radio, being the album's first single.^[38] Co-written by Musgraves, Shane McAnally, and Brandy Clark, Musgraves said the song's inspiration is just good ol' plum country fun".^[39] Its music video was released on June 10, premiering on BuzzFeed Music and serving as a "whimsical homage" to vintage television variety shows such as Laugh-In and The Lawrence Welk Show.^[40] Pageant Material's second single, "Dime Store Cowgirl", was first released on June 16, as the promotional single.^[41] It was sent to country radio on August 3, becoming the album's second single.^[42] She performed the track at Jimmy Kimmel Live on September 15^[28][43] and 2015 CMA Awards on November 4, with a stage set decorated with glitter, unicorns and rainbows,^[44][45] inspired from Lisa Frank.^[46]

To further support the album, Musgraves embarked on the Kacey Musgraves Country & Western Rhinestone Revue concert tour.^[47][48] Dates on the first leg included locations across the United State and Europe; the first leg of the tour began on August 27, 2015, in Atlanta, Georgia, and concluded on November 22, 2015, in Amsterdam, Netherlands.^[49] The band Sugar & The Hi-Lows was the opening act of the tour.^[50] The second leg of the tour, which spanned portions of the US, UK and Ireland, began in Dallas, TX on January 21, 2016,^[51][52] and concluded in Columbia, MO, on April 30, 2016.^[53]

Reviewing the show, Kelli Skye Fadroski of Orange County Register praised Musgraves for delivering a strong performance built around selections from Same Trailer Different Park and Pageant Material, highlighting her sharp songwriting and storytelling. The setlist also included several covers, such as "Three Little Birds" by Bob Marley and "Crazy" by Gnarls Barkley.^[54]

Pageant Material received positive reviews from music critics. At Metacritic, which assigns a normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream critics, the album has an average score of 78 out of 100, which indicates "generally favorable reviews" based on 25 reviews.^[56]

Writing for Hits Daily Double, Lenny Beer and Simon Glickman called Pageant Material an "album for the ages", comparing its greatness to Adele's 21, and described it as "a nearly perfect set".^[61] Stephen Thomas Erlewine of AllMusic stated: "Pageant Material favors softness, sometimes nearly swooning in its slowness, especially on the gorgeous keynote 'High Time' and the closer 'Fine' both so deliberate and hazy they evoke memories of lazy high-school dances."^[12] Billboard's Rob Tannenbaum claimed that it is "an even better album than her last, with more consistency and variety".^[58] Glenn Gamboa of Newsday called the record "great stories told extraordinarily well", and "nothing short of a musical miracle" in today's country music climate.^[62]

Glamour's Alexandra Schwartz listed Pageant Material among the best albums of 2015, calling it "nearly flawless".^[63] Paul Grein of Hits Daily Double predicted the album would be in contention for Album of the Year at the 58th Annual Grammy Awards.^[64] Additionally, it was the Spin magazine's "album of the week", described as a "sophomore masterpiece" by its reviewer Brennan Carley.^[13]

Pageant Material debuted at number three on the US Billboard 200 chart with 60,000 equivalent album units, selling 55,000 copies in its first week. It marked Musgraves' best week of album sales to date.^[86] The album also reached number one on the US Top Country Albums chart and the UK Country Albums chart,^[87][88] while peaking at number six in Canada,^[89] number 11 in the United Kingdom,^[90] number 33 in Australia,^[91] and number 30 in Norway.^[92] As of September 2016, it had sold 179,400 copies in the US.^[93]

On the year-end charts, the album appeared at number 181 on the US Billboard 200^[94] and number 26 on the US Top Country Albums chart in 2015,^[95] and at number 67 on the latter chart in 2016.^[96]

All tracks were produced by Luke Laird, Shane McAnally, and Kacey Musgraves.

• "Are You Sure" is a part of track 13 on CD pressings of the album (giving track 13 a length of 7:50), but a separate track on all other digital platforms. On all versions of the album, "Fine" ends at 3:37 and is followed by 18 seconds of silence.

Credits were adapted from AllMusic^[97] and liner notes.^[98]