History of horse-drawn transport
The history of horse-drawn transport has developed from antiquity to the present. For thousands of years, horse-drawn vehicles were the dominant means of overland travel, serving military, ceremonial, commercial, and everyday purposes before the invention of mechanized transport. Early examples include the chariots and carts of the ancient Near East and Mediterranean. By the medieval period, carriages with suspension systems and pivoting axles were used by royalty and aristocracy, while wagons and carts were essential for trade and agriculture. In the early modern period, with the spread of improved road surfaces such as macadam and tarmacadam, coaches and stagecoaches expanded long-distance travel, and horse-drawn trams and omnibuses transformed urban mobility in the 19th century. Although largely replaced by railways and automobiles in the 20th century, horse-drawn vehicles continue to be used today in rural areas, and for ceremonial and recreational purposes.
Cart history
The history of the cart is closely tied to the invention of the wheel. Pre-dating the wheel there were dragged devices like sledges and travois. The earliest known wheels date back to around 3400 to 3000 BC. The combination of the wheel and axle enabled the development of early wheeled vehicles which transformed human mobility and trade. The earliest wheeled vehicles had four-wheels (wagons), however two-wheeled vehicles (carts) required about 40% less pulling force than a four-wheeled vehicle of the same weight and were more maneuverable.[1][2][3]: 65-66
With the domestication of animals such as oxen and horses, carts became central to ancient economies. Animal‑drawn carts and wagons were widely used across civilizations for farming, trade, and migration. Their evolution—from solid wooden wheels to lighter spoked designs—marked a major technological advance, improving efficiency and enabling long‑distance transport.[4][3]
Some horse carts found in Celtic graves show hints that their platforms were suspended elastically.[5]
First prototyped in the 3rd millennium BC, a bullock cart is a large two-wheeled cart pulled by oxen or buffalo. It includes a sturdy wooden pole between the oxen, a yoke connecting a pair of oxen, a wooden platform for passengers or cargo, and large steel rimmed wooden wheels.[6][7]
Two-wheeled carriage models have been discovered from the Indus Valley Civilisation including twin horse drawn covered carriages resembling ekka from various sites such as Harappa, Mohenjo Daro and Chanhu Daro.[8] The earliest recorded sort of carriage was the chariot, reaching Mesopotamia as early as 1900 BC.[9] Used typically for warfare by Egyptians, the Near Easterners and Europeans, it was essentially a two-wheeled light basin carrying one or two standing passengers, drawn by one to two horses. The chariot was revolutionary and effective because it delivered fresh warriors to crucial areas of battle with swiftness.
Antiquity
Bronze Age Europe
Horses may have been driven even earlier. The Standard of Ur, in ancient Sumer, c. 2500 BC, shows horses or some type of onager or donkey hitched to wheeled carts with a yoke around their necks, in a manner similar to that of oxen.[10]
By the time of the Hyksos invasions of Egypt, c. 1600 BC, horses were pulling chariots with an improved harness design that made use of a breast collar and breeching, which allowed a horse to move faster and pull more weight.[11][10] The breast collar style harness is still used today for pulling lightweight vehicles.
Long before the horse collar harness, there was the less efficient throat-and-girth harness. This, it was claimed, could be found in many ancient civilizations, according to early 20th century French cavalry officer Richard Lefebvre des Noëttes.[12]: 304 This type of collar was supposedly used in ancient Chaldea, both Sumeria and Assyria (1400–800 BC), ancient Egypt during the New Kingdom (1570–1070 BC), Shang dynasty China (1600–1050 BC), Minoan Crete (2700–1450 BC), Classical Greece (550–323 BC), and ancient Rome (510 BC – 476 AD).[12]: 305–308 With this "ancient harness", ploughs and carts were pulled using harnesses that had flat straps across the neck and chest of the animal, with the load attached at the top of the collar, above the neck, in a manner similar to an oxen's yoke. These straps pressed against the horse's sterno-cephalicus muscle and trachea which restricted its breathing and reduced the pulling power of the horse.[12]: 305 Thus, the harder a horse pulled, the more strongly it choked off its own breathing. Because of these supposed physical constraints, oxen were preferred over horses for heavy work, as ox anatomy doesn't have this problem; standard yokes don't choke oxen.
Throughout the ancient world, the 'throat-and-girth' harness was used for harnessing horses that pulled carts; this greatly limited a horse's ability to exert itself as it was constantly choked at the neck.[12]: 305
Four-wheeled wagons were used in Bronze Age Europe, and their form known from excavations suggests that the basic construction techniques of wheel and undercarriage (that survived until the age of the motor car) were established then.[4][13]
Ancient Chinese carriages
While there is some anthropological evidence that horses were ridden before they were driven, the most unequivocal evidence of domestication and use of the horse as a driving animal are the Sintashta chariot burials in the southern Urals, circa 2000 BC. However, shortly thereafter, the expansion of the domestic horse throughout Europe was little short of explosive. In the space of possibly 500 years, there is evidence of horse-drawn chariots in Greece, Egypt, and Mesopotamia. By another 500 years, the horse-drawn chariot had spread to China.
The throat-girth design was not improved until the Chinese breast-strap or "breastcollar" harness developed during the Warring States (481–221 BC) era in China.[12]: 28 The Chinese breast harness became known throughout Central Asia by the 7th century,[12]: 311–315 and was introduced to Europe by the 8th century.[12]: 311–315
A painting on a lacquerware box from the State of Chu, dated to the 4th century BC, shows the first known use of a yoke placed across a horse's chest, with traces connecting to the chariot shaft.[12]: 310
Its first depiction in artwork was on lacquer-ware boxes from the ancient State of Chu.[12]: 310 This type of harness put pressure upon the sternum, where the line of traction is directly linked with the skeletal system of the horse, allowing for nearly full exertion.[12]: 305 It was in universal use by the time of the Chinese Han dynasty (202 BC – 220 AD), depicted in artwork of hundreds of different carvings, stone reliefs, and stamped bricks showing it featured on horses pulling chariots.[12]: 308–312 This type of breast-strap harness became known in Central Asia and elsewhere with the Avars, Magyars, Bohemians, Poles, and Russians during the 7th to 10th centuries.[12]: 311 After Central Asia, the first breast-strap harness was spread to Europe by the 8th century (in depicted artwork),[12]: 311–315 and became more widespread by the following 9th century (for example, depicted in a tapestry of the Oseberg ship burial).[12]: 316
Though the exact date of when the Chinese started to use carriages is largely unknown, early oracle bone inscriptions discovered in Henan province show that the carriage had already developed into many different forms. The earliest archaeological evidence of chariots in China, a chariot burial site discovered in 1933 at Hougang, Anyang in Henan province, dates to the rule of King Wu Ding of the late Shang dynasty (c. 1250 BCE). Oracle bone inscriptions suggest that the western enemies of the Shang used limited numbers of chariots in battle, but the Shang themselves used them only as mobile command-vehicles and in royal hunts.[14]
The hard yoke across the horse's chest was gradually replaced by a breast strap, which was often depicted in carved reliefs and stamped bricks of tombs from the Han Dynasty (202 BC – 220 AD).[12]: 308–312
During the Shang dynasty, members of the royal family were buried with a complete household and servants, including a chariot, horses, and a charioteer. A Shang chariot was often drawn by two horses, but four-horse variants are occasionally found in burials.
Jacques Gernet claims that the Zhou dynasty, which conquered the Shang ca. 1046 BCE, made more use of the chariot than did the Shang and "invented a new kind of harness with four horses abreast".[15] The crew consisted of an archer, a driver, and sometimes a third warrior who was armed with a spear or dagger-axe. From the 8th to 5th centuries BCE the Chinese use of chariots reached its peak. Although chariots appeared in greater numbers, infantry often defeated charioteers in battle.
Massed-chariot warfare became all but obsolete after the Warring-States Period (476–221 BCE). The main reasons were increased use of the crossbow, use of long halberds up to 18 feet (5.49 m) long and pikes up to 22 feet (6.71 m) long, and the adoption of standard cavalry units, and the adaptation of mounted archery from nomadic cavalry, which were more effective. Chariots would continue to serve as command posts for officers during the Qin dynasty (221–206 BCE) and the Han dynasty (206 BCE–220 CE), while armored chariots were also used during the Han dynasty against the Xiongnu Confederation in the Han–Xiongnu War (133 BC to 89 CE), specifically at the Battle of Mobei (119 BCE).
Before the Han dynasty, the power of Chinese states and dynasties was often measured by the number of chariots they were known to have. A country of a thousand chariots ranked as a medium country, and a country of ten thousand chariots ranked as a huge and powerful country.[16][17]
Medieval period
Even after the chariot had become obsolete as a tool of war, there still was a need for technological innovations in pulling technologies as larger horses were needed to pull heavier loads of both supplies and weapons. The invention of the horse collar in China during the 5th century (Southern and Northern Dynasties) allowed horses to pull greater weight than they could when hitched to a vehicle by means of the ox yokes or breast collars used in earlier times.[12]: 28, 317–322
The horse collar spread to Europe by the 9th century and became universal by the 12th century.[12]: 317 The Scandinavians were among the first to use a collar design that did not constrain the breathing passages of the horses.[18]: 109
When the horse was harnessed with a collar, it could apply roughly 50% more power to a task than an ox due to its greater speed.[19]: 162 [12]: 312 Horses also had greater endurance and could work more hours in a day. Europe’s long familiarity with horses made the transition from oxen-based harnesses to the collar relatively smooth.[20]: 345
The collar removed the physical restrictions of earlier harnesses, allowing the horse to exert its full strength in ploughing and transport. Originally, older harnesses forced the horse to pull its workload; the collar allowed the horse to push into the load instead, greatly increasing efficiency.[19]: 162
The medieval carriage was a sort of covered wagon. Sharing the traditional form of wheels and undercarriage known since the Bronze Age, it very likely also employed the pivoting fore-axle in continuity from the ancient world. Suspension (on chains) is recorded in visual images and written accounts from the 14th century ("chars branlant" or rocking carriages), and was in widespread use by the 15th century.[21] Carriages were largely used by royalty, aristocrats (and especially by women), and could be elaborately decorated and gilded. These carriages were usually on four wheels and were drawn by two to four horses depending on their size and status. Wood and iron were the primary materials needed to build a carriage and carriages that were used by non-royalty were covered by plain leather.
Another form of carriage was the pageant wagon of the 14th century. Historians debate the structure and size of pageant wagons; however, they are generally miniature house-like structures that rest on four to six wheels depending on the size of the wagon. The pageant wagon is significant because up until the 14th century most carriages were on two or three wheels; the chariot, rocking carriage, and baby carriage are two examples of carriages which pre-date the pageant wagon. Historians also debate whether or not pageant wagons were built with pivotal axle systems, which allowed the wheels to turn. Whether it was a four- or six-wheel pageant wagon, most historians maintain that pivotal axle systems were implemented on pageant wagons because many roads were often winding with some sharp turns. Six wheel pageant wagons also represent another innovation in carriages; they were one of the first carriages to use multiple pivotal axles. Pivotal axles were used on the front set of wheels and the middle set of wheels. This allowed the horse to move freely and steer the carriage in accordance with the road or path.
In the early 14th century England, coaches were still extremely rare. It is unlikely there were more than a dozen, and even then they were very costly until the end of the century. These coaches had four six-spoke, six-foot high wheels that were linked by greased axles under the body of the coach and they had no suspension. The chassis was made from oak beams and the barrel shaped roof was covered in brightly painted leather or cloth. The interior included seats, beds, cushions, tapestries and even rugs. They were pulled by four to five horses.[22]
Early modern period
One of the great innovations in carriage history was the invention of the suspended carriage or the chariot branlant (though whether this was a Roman or medieval innovation remains uncertain). The "chariot branlant" of medieval illustrations was suspended by chains rather than leather straps as had been believed.[23][24] Suspension, whether on chains or leather, might provide a smoother ride since the carriage body no longer rested on the axles, but could not prevent swinging (branlant) in all directions. It is clear from illustrations (and surviving examples) that the medieval suspended carriage with a round tilt was a widespread European type, referred to by any number of names (car, currus, char, chariot).
Under King Mathias Corvinus (1458–90), who enjoyed fast travel, the Hungarians developed fast road transport, and the town of Kocs between Budapest and Vienna became an important post-town, and gave its name to the new vehicle type.[25][26] The earliest illustrations of the Hungarian "Kochi-wagon" do not indicate any suspension, a body with high sides of lightweight wickerwork, and typically drawn by three horses in harness. Later models were considerably lighter and famous for a single horse being able to draw many passengers.[27]
The Hungarian coach spread across Europe, initially rather slowly, in part due to Ippolito d'Este of Ferrara (1479–1520), nephew of Mathias' queen Beatrix of Aragon, who as a very junior Archbishopric of Esztergom developed a taste for Hungarian riding and took his carriage and driver back to Italy.[21]: 51 Then rather suddenly, in around 1550, the "coach" made its appearance throughout the major cities of Europe, and the new word entered the vocabulary of all their languages.[28] However, the new "coach" seems to have been a fashionable concept (fast road travel for men) as much as any particular type of vehicle, and there is no obvious technological change that accompanied the innovation, either in the use of suspension (which came earlier), or the adoption of springs (which came later). As its use spread throughout Europe in the late 16th century, the coach's body structure was ultimately changed, from a round-topped tilt to the "four-poster" carriages that became standard everywhere by c.1600.[21]: 41–53
Coaches had doors in the side, with an iron step protected by leather that became the "boot" in which servants might ride. The driver sat on a seat at the front, and the most important occupant sat in the back facing forwards. The earliest coaches can be seen at Veste Coburg, Lisbon, and the Moscow Kremlin, and they become a commonplace in European art. It was not until the 17th century that further innovations with steel springs and glazing took place, and only in the 18th century, with better road surfaces, was there a major innovation with the introduction of the steel C-spring.[29]
One source says that in, "1564, Boonen, a Dutchman, became the Queen's coachman, and was the first that brought the use of coaches into England."[30]: 675 Another source says it was not until 1580, in the reign of Queen Elizabeth I, that coaches were introduced to England from France by Henry FitzAlan, 19th Earl of Arundel.[31] These were designed to be pulled by a pair of horses. In 1619 George Villiers, 1st Duke of Buckingham introduced the coach drawn by six horses.[32]
In 1772, Robert Norris described the use of two coaches in Dahomey during a ceremonial procession. They were drawn by 12 men instead of horses probably as a result of the small number of horses in Dahomey.[33]
Late modern period
18th-century suspension and coach design
In the eighteenth century, many coaches were still suspended on long leather straps known as thoroughbraces. Steel springs were also introduced during this period, offering a more comfortable ride. An advertisement in the Edinburgh Courant for 1754 reads, "The Edinburgh stage-coach, for the better accommodation of passengers, will be altered to a new genteel two-end glass coach-machine, hung on steel springs, exceedingly light and easy..."
Thoroughbraces were gradually replaced by various configurations of steel springs as these were invented, but they did not disappear entirely. The 19th‑century American Concord coach famously retained leather strap suspension for its durability on rough terrain.
19th-century technological innovations
Many innovations were proposed, and some patented, for new types of suspension and steering. In the late 18th century, the English physician Erasmus Darwin identified two major shortcomings in contemporary light carriages: the jarring ride caused by small front wheels on a pivoting axle, and the danger of overturning when the axle turned too sharply. He proposed a system in which the two front wheels would turn independently, improving stability and reducing strain on the horses. This principle was later patented in 1818 as Ackermann steering, in which the front wheels turn at different angles so that each follows the correct turning radius. The design became a standard feature of 19th-century vehicles.
In the 1880s, several Parisian coachbuilders experimented with electrical accessories. Felber & Fils exhibited a coupé equipped with an electric order-transmitter that allowed passengers to signal instructions to the coachman using a telegraph-style dial and bell. They also demonstrated an electrically actuated odometer that registered hectometers and kilometers using wheel-triggered contacts.[34]
By the late 19th century, European coachbuilders introduced a series of refinements that pushed horse-drawn vehicles toward their final technological peak. Innovations included improved running-gear designs such as the avant-train excentrique (eccentric fore-carriage), which enhanced maneuverability in urban streets, and the adoption of solid rubber tyres that reduced vibration and road noise. Interior comfort also advanced with concealed folding seats (strapontins invisibles), which could be deployed when needed without altering the appearance of the passenger compartment. Bodywork experimentation produced hybrid forms such as landaus fitted with rigid, fabric-lined panels in place of the traditional folding leather top. Some builders also adapted to new cultural trends, offering systems for transporting bicycles during the cycling boom of the 1890s. Firms such as Felber of Paris, active from the 1830s and repeatedly recognized at international exhibitions, were among those who adopted and publicized these late-century innovations.[34]
-
The Grand Gala Berlin constructed 1824–1826 for Leo XII
-
The London-Farringdon coach, 1835
Carriage use in North America
The development and use of carriages in North America followed a different trajectory from Europe, shaped by colonial settlement patterns, road conditions, and regional economies. Carriage use in North America came with the establishment of European settlers. Early colonial horse tracks quickly grew into roads especially as the colonists extended their territories southwest. Colonists began using carts as these roads and trading increased between the north and south. Eventually, carriages or coaches were sought to transport goods as well as people. As in Europe, chariots, coaches and carriages were a mark of status. The tobacco planters of the South were some of the first Americans to use the carriage as a form of human transportation. As the tobacco farming industry grew in the southern colonies so did the frequency of carriages, coaches and wagons. Upon the turn of the 18th century, wheeled vehicle use in the colonies was at an all-time high. Carriages, coaches and wagons were being taxed based on the number of wheels they had. These taxes were implemented in the South primarily as the South had superior numbers of horses and wheeled vehicles when compared to the North. Europe, however, still used carriage transportation far more often and on a much larger scale than anywhere else in the world.
Decline of the horse-drawn era
With the invention of the automobile, the tractor and other internal combustion vehicles, the need for driving horses diminished, beginning with the end of World War I and to an even greater degree after World War II. However, interest in driving competition for horses continued, with the horse show and harness racing worlds keeping interest alive, and the development of the sport of combined driving continued to refine the art of proper training and driving techniques. In addition, many third world nations retain a need for driving horses for basic farm work and transportation.
Carriages and coaches began to disappear as use of steam propulsion began to generate more and more interest and research. Steam power quickly won the battle against animal power as is evident by a newspaper article written in England in 1895 entitled "Horseflesh vs. Steam".[35][36] The article highlights the death of the carriage as the main means of transportation.
In the 19th century the word "coach" was used for U.S. railway carriages,[37] and in the 20th century to motor coaches.
Contemporary use
Carriages are still used for day-to-day transport in the United States by some groups such as the Amish, and they are used in urban centers around the world for tourists and sightseeing. The Royal Mews in London holds a large collection of coaches and carriages regularly used by the Royal Household, particularly during ceremonial events such as the carriage processions at the beginning of each day of Royal Ascot.
See also
References
- ^ Hirst, K. Kris (September 20, 2018) [April 4, 2012]. "The Invention of the Wheel and Wheeled Vehicles : The Impact of Wheeled Vehicles on Human History". ThoughtCo.
- ^ Kleinschmidt, H. E. (October 1944). "Evolution of the Wheel". The Scientific Monthly. 59 (4): 273–282. Bibcode:1944SciMo..59..273K. JSTOR 18250.
- ^ a b Anthony, David W. (2007). The Horse, the Wheel, and Language : How Bronze-Age Riders from the Eurasian Steppes Shaped the Modern World. Princeton University Press. ISBN 9780691058870. OL 11182657M.
- ^ a b Piggott, Stuart (1983). The Earliest Wheeled Transport. Thames and Hudson. ISBN 9780801416040. OL 22097205M.
- ^ Raimund Karl (2003). "Überlegungen zum Verkehr in der eisenzeitlichen Keltiké" [Deliberations on Traffic in the Ironage Celtic Culture] (PDF) (in German). Universität Wien. Archived from the original (PDF) on April 11, 2008. Retrieved January 30, 2008.
- ^ "Bullock carts". Singapore Infopedia. Retrieved November 17, 2021.
- ^ Wolpert, Stanley (1994). An Introduction to India. Penguin Books India. p. 5. ISBN 9780140168709. OL 24238499M.
- ^ Piggott, Stuart (1970). "Copper Vehicle-Models in the Indus Civilization". The Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland. 102 (2): 200–202. doi:10.1017/S0035869X00128394. JSTOR 25203212. S2CID 163967541.
- ^ Tarr, László (1969). The History of the Carriage. New York: Arco Publishing Company. ISBN 0668018712. OL 5682797M.
- ^ a b Chamberlin, J. Edward. Horse: How the Horse Has Shaped Civilizations. Bluebridge, 2006, p. 166-167 ISBN 0-9742405-9-1
- ^ Edwards, Gladys Brown. The Arabian: War Horse to Show Horse. Arabian Horse Association of Southern California, Revised Collector's Edition, Rich Publishing, 1973.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r Needham, Joseph (1986). "Part 2: Mechanical Engineering". Science and Civilisation in China. Physics and Physical Technology. Vol. 4. Cambridge University Press.
- ^ Pare, C.F.E (1992). Wagons and Wagon-Graves of the Early Iron Age in Central Europe. Oxford. ISBN 0947816356.
- ^ Shaughnessy, Edward L. (1988). "Historical Perspectives on The Introduction of The Chariot Into China". Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies. 48 (1): 189–237. doi:10.2307/2719276. JSTOR 2719276.
- ^ Gernet, Jacques (1996). A History of Chinese Civilization (2nd ed.). Cambridge University Press. p. 51. ISBN 0-521-49781-7.
- ^ [Mencius · Liang Hui Huang (King the Hui of Liang, Hui is a posthumous name) Volume One] 'The kingslayer of a country of ten thousands chariots, must be the house of thousand chariots. The kingslayer of a country of thousand chariots, must be the house of hundred chariots.' [Zhao Qi's note] Zhao Qi's note: ' Ten thousands chariots, is the son of heaven (King of Zhou).'
- ^ [Zhan Guo Ce·Zhao Ce] 'Nowadays, Kingdom of Qin is a country of ten thousands chariots, Kingdom of Liang (Kingdom of Wei, 'Da Liang' is the capital of Wei) is also a country of ten thousands chariots.'
- ^ Chamberlain, J. Edward (2006). Horse: How the Horse Has Shaped Civilizations. Virginia: Blue Bridge. OL 7695279M.
- ^ a b Riddle, John M. (2008). A History of the Middle Ages, 300–1500. Rowman & Littlefield. OL 10721714M.
- ^ Braudel, Fernand (1992). Civilization and Capitalism, 15th–18th Century: The Structure of Everyday Life. University of California Press.
- ^ a b c Munby, Julian (2008), "From Carriage to Coach: What Happened?", in Bork, Robert; Kahn, Andrea (eds.), The Art, Science, and Technology of Medieval Travel, Ashgate, pp. 41–53
- ^ Mortimer, Ian (2009). The time traveller's guide to medieval England : a handbook for visitors to the fourteenth century. London: Vintage. pp. 133–134. ISBN 978-1-84595-099-6.
- ^ Léon marquis De Laborde. Glossaire français du Moyen Age. Labitte, Paris, 1872. p. 208.
- ^ Munby, Julian (2008), "From Carriage to Coach: What Happened?", in Bork, Robert; Kahn, Andrea (eds.), The Art, Science, and Technology of Medieval Travel, Ashgate, p. 45
- ^ "coach". Collins English Dictionary. HarperCollins. OCLC 1120411289. Retrieved November 20, 2021.
- ^ "Coach". Oxford English Dictionary (1st ed.). Oxford University Press. 1933.
- ^ "coach (horse-drawn vehicle)". Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved November 20, 2021.
- ^ Etymology for Coach in Oxford English Dictionary, Second Edition. Oxford University Press, 1989.
- ^ Straus, Ralph (1912). Carriages & Coaches: Their History & Their Evolution. London: Martin Secker. pp. 204 ff.
- ^ The National Cyclopaedia of Useful Knowledge, Vol IV (1848 ed.). London: Charles Knight.
- ^ Percy, S.; Percy, R. (1823). The Percy Anecdotes. T. Boys. pp. 54–55. Retrieved October 12, 2014.
- ^ Chambers, Robert (1832). "August 22". The Book of Days. p. 253.
- ^ Law, Robin (1980). "Wheeled Transport in Pre-Colonial West Africa". Africa: Journal of the International African Institute. 50 (3): 249–262. doi:10.2307/1159117. JSTOR 1159117.
- ^ a b Magnaudeix, Patrick (January 19, 2026). "Catalogue 1889 de la carrosserie Felber" [Felber body catalog 1889]. attelage-patrimoine.com [Horse‑Drawn Heritage] (in French).
- ^ Mechanical Road Carriages: Horseflesh V. Steam. The British Medical Journal, Vol. 2, No. 1823 (7 December 1895), pp. 1434–1435. BMJ Publishing Group
- ^ "Mechanical Road Carriages: Horseflesh v. Steam". British Medical Journal. 2 (1823): 1434–1435. December 7, 1895. ISSN 0007-1447. PMC 2509017. PMID 20755870.
- ^ Oxford English Dictionary